Method — Validation State

Definition

A validation state represents the current status of assessed validity relative to defined criteria, evidence, constraints, or expectations.

It establishes a framework for identifying validity status without prescribing validation procedures, certification mechanisms, or domain-specific approval systems.

Model Classification

The validation state model is structured as a descriptive and analytical reference model.

It provides a framework for examining relationships between claims, evidence, assessment criteria, and validity status without defining operational procedures, regulatory approvals, or commercial audit services.

Scope Boundary

Included

Excluded

Structural Phase Model

Phase 1 — State or Claim Identification

A claim, behavior, result, or system state is identified within the assessment context.

Phase 2 — Evidence Incorporation

Evidence, observations, assessments, or tests are incorporated relative to defined criteria.

Phase 3 — Validity Assessment

The available evidence is assessed in relation to criteria, constraints, or expectations.

Phase 4 — Validation State

The current status of assessed validity is represented as a validation state.

State Structure Model

Unassessed State

No validity assessment has been established.

Assessed State

Evidence or assessment has been applied relative to defined criteria.

Validated State

Available assessment supports validity relative to defined criteria.

Uncertain State

Available assessment does not support a stable validity determination.

Transferability

The validation state model is not limited to a specific domain or technology.

It can be applied across information systems, knowledge systems, software systems, artificial intelligence systems, scientific assessment contexts, and human-machine decision environments.

The model remains consistent by focusing on structural relationships between claims, evidence, criteria, and assessed validity status.